The race toward the first U.S.-approved bitcoin spot exchange-traded fund (ETF) is intensifying, with Grayscale Investments expressing strong optimism about the pending approval of its long-awaited application. The digital asset manager has confirmed plans to transition its Grayscale Bitcoin Trust (GBTC) from the OTCQX market to the NYSE Arca exchange — a strategic move widely seen as the final step before converting GBTC into a full-fledged bitcoin spot ETF.
If approved by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), this transformation would mark a pivotal moment in crypto finance, potentially closing the persistent gap between GBTC’s share price and the underlying value of bitcoin. As of early December 2023, GBTC was trading at an 8.09% discount to its net asset value (NAV), representing a valuation gap of approximately $1.89 billion. Converting to an ETF structure would allow for daily creation and redemption of shares, aligning its market price much more closely with bitcoin’s actual price.
👉 Discover how ETF approval could reshape crypto investing in 2025.
Why the NYSE Arca Listing Matters
The shift from OTCQX to NYSE Arca is not just a change in ticker location — it’s a structural upgrade. Currently, GBTC operates as a closed-end trust, meaning new shares cannot be created or redeemed freely. This lack of arbitrage mechanisms has allowed the discount to persist, discouraging some institutional investors.
By moving to NYSE Arca, Grayscale is preparing GBTC for an open-ended ETF model where authorized participants can issue or redeem shares daily based on demand. This mechanism is crucial for maintaining price parity with bitcoin and enhancing liquidity.
Craig Salm, Grayscale’s General Counsel, and Edward McGee, Chief Financial Officer, recently outlined the significance of this transition in a public blog post. While the SEC continues its review process, the company is proactively aligning its operational framework with ETF standards — a signal of confidence in eventual approval.
Regulatory Hurdles: The Role of Regulation M
Despite growing optimism, regulatory scrutiny remains intense. One key factor now in focus is Regulation M, a set of SEC rules designed to prevent market manipulation during securities offerings. Bloomberg ETF analyst Eric Balchunas highlighted that Grayscale’s mention of Regulation M relief shortly after meeting with the SEC is “notable” — suggesting it could be a potential hurdle or even a tactical delay tactic by regulators.
“The ‘reliant on Reg M relief’ is notable… I had heard something a while ago about Reg M being the poss ‘parking ticket’ that SEC would use to keep them from the Starting Gate. Not saying this proves it but it is notable that they’re mentioning it, esp right after meeting w SEC.”
— Eric Balchunas (@EricBalchunas), December 1, 2023
Some experts interpret this as a sign that the SEC may allow approvals but impose temporary restrictions to monitor market impact — a cautious yet permissive approach.
Market Reaction: Bitcoin Surges Past $41,000
Investor sentiment has responded strongly to the evolving ETF landscape. Bitcoin broke through the $40,000 mark in early December 2023, reaching $41,453 at the time of writing — a roughly 5% gain over 24 hours. Trading volume spiked across major exchanges, reflecting heightened anticipation.
This momentum isn’t isolated. Analysts like James Seyffart from Bloomberg have noted that the SEC’s decision timeline has shifted multiple times, most recently pushing back rulings by 34 days ahead of the initial January 1, 2024 deadline. However, both Seyffart and Balchunas now estimate a 90% probability that one or more bitcoin spot ETFs — including Grayscale’s — will be approved by January 10, 2024.
Such confidence stems from precedent: the SEC has already approved several bitcoin futures ETFs. With growing institutional demand and clearer custodial frameworks, many believe resistance to a spot version is fading.
👉 See how major financial shifts are driving bitcoin adoption worldwide.
What Approval Means for Investors
Approval of a bitcoin spot ETF would represent a watershed moment for mainstream crypto adoption. It would provide:
- Regulated exposure to bitcoin through traditional brokerage accounts.
- Enhanced transparency via daily reporting and SEC oversight.
- Improved price efficiency, eliminating long-standing discounts like GBTC’s.
- Easier access for retirement accounts, pension funds, and conservative investors.
For Grayscale, conversion means transforming GBTC from a premium/discount-prone instrument into a liquid, tradable asset that accurately reflects bitcoin’s market value. It also positions the firm to compete directly with other asset managers like BlackRock, Fidelity, and Ark Invest, all of whom have filed competing spot ETF applications.
FAQ: Your Bitcoin ETF Questions Answered
Q: What is a bitcoin spot ETF?
A: A bitcoin spot ETF directly holds actual bitcoin and tracks its real-time market price. Unlike futures-based ETFs, it doesn’t rely on derivative contracts, offering more accurate exposure to bitcoin’s true value.
Q: Why has the SEC delayed approval?
A: The SEC has historically cited concerns about market manipulation, custody risks, and investor protection. However, improved infrastructure and regulated custodians have addressed many of these issues over time.
Q: Will GBTC’s discount disappear after ETF conversion?
A: Yes — once GBTC becomes an ETF with creation/redemption mechanisms, arbitrage will keep its price in line with bitcoin’s net value, effectively eliminating the discount.
Q: How soon could trading begin on NYSE Arca?
A: If approved by January 10, 2024, the transition could happen within weeks. Grayscale has indicated it’s operationally ready for listing.
Q: Can I buy GBTC now and benefit later?
A: Potentially. Investors holding GBTC before conversion may see gains if the discount narrows post-approval. However, this involves risk and depends on final regulatory decisions.
Q: Are other companies also applying for bitcoin spot ETFs?
A: Yes — BlackRock, Fidelity, Ark/21Shares, VanEck, and others have filed applications. Approval could lead to multiple competing products entering the market.
The Road Ahead: A New Era for Crypto Investing
Grayscale’s push to list GBTC on NYSE Arca signals more than just regulatory readiness — it reflects a broader shift in how digital assets are being integrated into traditional finance. With bitcoin surpassing $41,000 and institutional interest surging, the stars may finally be aligning for a historic approval.
While challenges remain — particularly around Regulation M and final SEC clearance — momentum is undeniably building. Whether it happens in January 2024 or shortly after, the launch of a U.S. bitcoin spot ETF will open new doors for millions of investors seeking secure, transparent access to cryptocurrency markets.
👉 Stay ahead of the next market breakthrough with real-time crypto insights.